What is Bayesian Analysis?

Alexandre Bouchard-Côté

Poll

What characterizes “Bayesian Analysis”?

  1. MAP estimators (maximum a posteriori)
  2. posterior means
  3. Bayes rule
  4. models where some unknown quantities are treated as random
  5. none of the above

What characterizes “Bayesian Analysis”?

All these popular answers are misleading and/or very incomplete:

  1. MAP estimators (maximum a posteriori)
    • MAP is seldom used by expert Bayesians (mode is misleading in high dimensions)
  2. posterior means
    • the posterior mean is often undefined (e.g. Bayesian analysis over combinatorial objects)
  3. Bayes rule
    • Bayes rule is intractable in most practical situations (we use MCMC/variational methods)
  4. models where some unknown quantities are treated as random
    • true for Bayesian models, but also for many non-Bayesian models, e.g., random effect models

So???

What is Bayesian Analysis???

Preview of key definitions

Bayesian Analysis: statistical discipline centered around the use of Bayes estimators

Bayes estimators: for data \(X\), unobserved \(Z\), loss \(L\), and possible actions \({\mathcal{A}}\), the Bayes estimator is defined as:

\[{\textrm{argmin}}\{ {\mathbf{E}}[L(a, Z) | X] : a \in {\mathcal{A}}\}\]

This course

The primary objective of this course is to understand Bayes estimators:

Readings for first week (read before next Tuesday)

Christian Robert, The Bayesian Choice, 2nd edition.